Garowe-(Puntland Mirror) The Garowe local government has given owners of brick and aluminium factories operating within the city 10 days to relocate, saying the move is part of efforts to implement the city’s master plan.
In a letter issued by the office of the local government’s executive secretary on Nov. 12, the authorities said the relocation was intended to protect public health, improve the city’s appearance, ease traffic congestion and address noise and heavy vehicle movements associated with factory operations.
However, Abdirahman Abshir Jama, an economist and public policy expert, questioned the short deadline, the lack of designated relocation sites and the absence of an assessment of the decision’s economic impact.
“The purpose of the letter is sound. Noise, dust and heavy vehicles from these types of factories are real problems for people living nearby. But the way the decision is being implemented raises a number of questions,” Abdirahman said.
He said 10 days was not enough time to move factories equipped with machinery and heavy equipment, which would require considerable time and money to relocate.
He also criticised the local government for failing to identify where the factories should move, saying it should first establish a designated industrial area.
“Governments should not simply tell businesses to move to ‘suitable locations’ without identifying those locations. The local government should assess the options, plan and designate an industrial area, then tell businesses where to relocate,” he said.

Abdirahman said the letter provided no evidence of the problems caused by the factories, such as noise measurements, dust levels or complaints from nearby residents.
He also questioned why a technical committee was expected to inspect and assess the proposed sites after the relocation order had already been issued. Such an assessment, he said, should have taken place before the decision was made.
The letter does not mention whether the local government consulted factory owners, workers or residents of the affected neighbourhoods.
Abdirahman warned that relocating the factories could have wider economic consequences, given the role of brick production in the city’s construction sector.
If factories close or production costs rise as a result of the move, building material prices and construction costs could increase, he said. Workers and families whose livelihoods depend on the industry could also lose their jobs and income.
He called on the local government to assess the economic and environmental impact of the relocation, consult affected parties and prepare the new sites before enforcing the order.
He also proposed giving factory owners three to six months, or another period agreed with them, to move their operations. The local government could support the process by offering public land at reduced rent or free of charge for a limited period, or by providing temporary tax relief to help businesses meet relocation costs.
The decision comes as Garowe seeks to manage its urban growth and regulate land use. Implementing the city’s master plan will require balancing public health and urban planning needs with the economic interests of businesses and workers.
“Good policy should always serve the interests of the public, and policymaking often involves difficult choices. It is important that policies are developed and implemented carefully and with proper consideration,” Abdirahman said.
He added that Garowe needed planned development that did not unnecessarily harm businesses or the people who depend on them.
The local government’s letter did not specify the sites where the factories would be relocated or outline any financial support for affected businesses.
